Deerskin

McKinley, Robin. Deerskin (1993). 309 Pages. Ace Fantasy. $7.99

Warning: This book deals with rape an other “adult” themes.

From the Cover:

As Princess Lissar reaches womanhood, it is clear to all the kingdom that in her breathtaking beauty she is the mirror image of her mother, the queen. But this seeming blessing forces her to flee for safety from her father’s wrath. With her loyal dog Ash at her side, Lissar unlocks a door to a world of magic, where she finds the key to her survival– and an adventure beyond her wildest dreams…

First Lines

Many years later she remembered how her parents had looked to her when she was a small child: her father as tall as a tree, and merry and bright and golden, with her beautiful black-haired mother at his side. She saw them, remembered them, as if she were looking at a painting; they were too splendid to be real, and always they seemed at some little distance from her, from all onlookers. They were always standing close together as she remembered them, often gazing into each other’s eyes, often handclasped, often smiling; and always there was a radiance like sunlight flung around them.

Thoughts

I would class Deerskin as a difficult read. It requires a certain maturity, and a certain mindset to get through it. It deals with rape– it is vivid, though not explicit– and long-lasting aftermath and emotional scars. It is not a book for young readers, or people looking for a light read. I feel the need to preface it this way, because I feel like if you’re going to read a book with sexual violence, you should be prepared for it. I have denounced books before for using rape as a plot device, but that is for using it lightly. It is not used lightly here.

Occasionally, I feel compelled to re-read Deerskin, knowing that I have trouble with the first part of the book, because it is still a good book. It is not one which I read lightly. As odd as it sounds, it can be comforting when you’re miserable to read about someone who is more miserable than you. When I first encountered Deerskin, it was during one of the worst periods of my life, and reading about Lissar and her healing helped me. Now I re-read it because it reminds me how much better things are now.

I cannot say that I suggest it, precisely. Especially if you’re a McKinley fan, because it is both like and unlike her other books. There is a nod to Aerin and Maur, and in many ways the prose is the same style, but the subject matter is distinctly different.  It is based on Charles Perrault’s Donkeyskin, which is a creepy enough fairy tale without adding violence.

As much as it may not sound like I enjoy it, I do like this book to re-read it. Lissar is a difficult character to empathize with, because of her circumstances, but also because of her emotional damage. She doesn’t remember much, which is a difficult conceit to pull off without being soap-opera-y, but it’s done well, here. Chapter seventeen is where I typically start enjoying the book, because it shifts focus a bit.

I do have a bit of trouble with the climactic scene. It’s over-the-top, and I don’t particularly enjoy that. I can’t say a lot more without spoiling it, but I can’t maintain my suspension of disbelief, because it’s too awkward. Add to that a rather stilted denouement, and it’s not wholly satisfying. The after is what I am most interested by, when I think about this particular title.

When all is said and done, I’d give this a solid 4/5. I re-read it, and I enjoy reading it, though it is a bit heavy for my typical taste.

________________________________

If you choose to buy this book, please consider doing so via this link. It gets me referral credit with amazon associates.

8 Comments

Filed under Adult Fiction, Book Review, Fairy Tales Retold, Fantasy, High Fantasy

8 responses to “Deerskin

  1. Mumsy

    I entirely agree with you regarding the climactic scene. I always want to sigh and shake my head. But I like the book because I think McKinley made an honest effort to grapple with a powerful issue, using symbolic imagery – and I think she is mostly successful. And also because I love the dogs.

    Like

    • I do love the dogs, too. I’ve only ever had stocky, energetic, non-graceful labs. They were amazing, and I loved them, but Deerskin made me want… graceful dogs.

      Like

  2. I read Deerskin right on the heels of reading another book that includes rape in a suitably horrifying way (Kindred by Octavia Butler). I may not have been too young for Deerskin, but I was way too young for Kindred, and reading the two together was very traumatic for 12-year-old me. They’re still linked in my head and I haven’t reread either of them since. Maybe it’s time to reread them, though…

    Like

    • I do think that re-reading things like that can be rewarding, because it can fix it. But it can also be disappointing, because sometimes it doesn’t fix it. If you do decide to re-read, I hope it helps.

      Like

  3. Mia

    I’ve been interested in reading this–and Robin McKinley in general–for a while. We were originally going to read it one month for live-action book club, but the girl who chose it ultimately decided that the rape scene was too heavy and switched her choice to Howl’s Moving Castle instead. I’ll have to pick this up when I’m not in a particularly fragile mood and give it a go.

    Do you have any other suggestions for other McKinley titles? My local library only has her vampire book, and I’m not sure I want to use that as my entry point into her work. (I’ve been interested in Chalice, but a friend of a friend read it and HATED it.)

    Like

    • The books of hers which hooked me were her Damar books– The Hero & The Crown and The Blue Sword. They’re both pretty fantastic if you’re looking for Fantasy.

      I liked Sunshine, but it’s more… Urban Fantasy? It’s good, and I like it, but it’s not my very favorite of her books. I’d start with Damar, and if you like those, then try Sunshine or others.

      (I thought Chalice was good, but it wasn’t exactly her best.)

      Like

  4. Ela

    I know what you mean about liking ‘Deerskin’ but not necessarily enjoying it. I actually rather liked that climactic scene, since it said to me that Lissar was finally doing something strong, of her own volition, rather than being prodded by external events.

    I really liked McKinley’s Sleeping Beauty retelling (which title I can’t now for the life of me remember): that or ‘Beauty’ would be good places to start.

    Like

    • Spindle’s End is the title you’re trying to think of. It’s one of my favorite Sleeping Beauty versions.

      At the end, it’s the blood I most have trouble with. It feels… gross, cheesy, and over-the-top. Like a B-list horror/action movie where there are literal blood geysers every time someone gets cut. I don’t think I’ll ever truly like that bit.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s